How to choose a coach: 5 things to look for
Thinking about working with a coach, but not sure where to start? Here’s what to look for, what to ask and how to find someone who’s right for you.

Deciding to work with a coach is one thing; finding the right one is another.
A quick search will bring up hundreds of coaches, all promising to help you unlock your potential, achieve your goals or transform your life, but how do you know who’s actually right for you?
The truth is, there isn’t one perfect coach for everyone. Someone who works brilliantly with your colleague or friend might not be the right fit for you, and that’s absolutely fine.
Here are 5 things to consider before making your decision:
1. Look for someone you feel comfortable talking to
This is probably the most important one.
Coaching involves being open and honest. Sometimes about things you haven’t even admitted to yourself yet.
You might talk about your confidence, your frustrations, your ambitions or the things you’re worried other people might think. You need to feel comfortable enough to have those conversations, and to potentially be quite vulnerable.
That doesn’t mean your coach should always agree with you; in fact it’s quite the opposite. A good coach will challenge your thinking, ask difficult questions and occasionally make you feel a little uncomfortable, but there should always be trust and respect behind those conversations.
My tip: Book an introductory conversation before committing. Notice how you feel afterwards. Did you feel listened to? Could you be yourself? Did they seem genuinely interested in understanding you? Simply put – did you click?
2. Check their qualifications and experience
In the UK, coaching isn’t a legally regulated profession, which means someone can call themselves a coach without having completed any formal training.
I’m not saying that qualifications are everything, but they’re a very useful starting point.
Look for relevant coaching training, recognised qualifications and evidence that they take their professional development seriously.
You might also want to ask about their practical experience. Have they worked with people facing similar challenges? Do they understand the environment you’re working in? Finally, don’t be afraid to ask how they approach confidentiality and professional ethics.
My tip: Look for recognised coaching qualifications and professional bodies such as the ICF, EMCC or Association for Coaching. Membership or accreditation can offer additional reassurance, although they’re not the only indicators of a good coach.
3. Think about what you want help with
Not all coaches do the same thing, and you’re going to want one who can really understand your situation. Some specialise in career progression, others in executive leadership, business development, confidence or personal development.
It’s important to spend a little time thinking about why you’re considering coaching, to help you narrow down the huge pool of potential coaches. Perhaps you want to progress in your career but keep holding yourself back. Maybe you’ve stepped into a leadership role and aren’t quite sure how you want to lead. Or perhaps everything looks fine on paper, but something doesn’t feel right.
You don’t need to arrive with a perfectly defined goal – in fact exploring what you actually want can be part of the coaching process – but having a general idea will help you find someone with relevant experience.
My tip: Don’t just look at a coach’s list of services. Read how they talk about the challenges their clients face. Do you recognise yourself in what they’re describing?
4. Understand how they work
Coaching isn’t the same as mentoring, counselling or consulting.
A coach generally won’t tell you what decision to make or hand you a ready-made solution; instead, they’ll help you explore your thinking, challenge your assumptions and work towards your own answers. That said, different coaches have different approaches.
Some use structured programmes and exercises, whereas others offer more flexible, conversation-led sessions. Some might specialise in specific techniques or frameworks aimed at very specific challenges, and others might rely on their experience to get the best out of their clients.
None of these approaches is automatically better than another – what’s important is finding one that works for you.
My tip: Ask what a typical session looks like, whether you’ll set goals together and how you’ll review your progress. Be cautious of anyone guaranteeing a particular outcome.
5. Be clear about the practicalities
Coaching is an investment of both time and money, so it’s worth understanding exactly what you’re committing to.
Before agreeing to anything, check:
- How long are the sessions, and how often will you meet?
- Do you need to commit to a package, or can you book individual sessions?
- What’s included in the price?
- What happens if you need to cancel or rearrange?
- How will confidentiality work, particularly if your employer is paying?
- How will you know whether the coaching is helping?
A good coach should be happy to explain all of this without making you feel pressured into signing up. And remember, a higher price doesn’t automatically mean a better coach.
So, why might you choose me?
I’m not going to tell you I’m the perfect coach for everyone – I’m not – but I might be the right coach for you.
At GMW Coaching & Leadership, I work with capable people who know they’ve got more to offer, but aren’t quite sure how to get there.
People who are ready for their next career move but keep questioning themselves, future leaders who don’t yet see what everyone else sees in them, and experienced professionals who need somewhere to think without the expectations and opinions of everyone around them.
I’m accredited at practitioner level with the EMCC. I bring real experience of working with people and teams, and a background in leadership, Agile Coaching and facilitation.
More than that though, I bring curiosity, warmth and a willingness to challenge you when it’s needed. I’m not here to tell you what you should be doing with your career; I’m here to help you recognise what’s possible, question what’s getting in the way and work out what you want to do next. I want to create the space that busy professionals often lack to really think about where you are, where you want to be, and how you’re going to get there.
My approach is conversational, practical and tailored to you. I may use tools and techniques where appropriate, but I’m more interested in making the time work for you. There’s no expectation that you’ll arrive knowing exactly what you want to achieve, and no pressure to have everything figured out.
Sometimes we’ll explore big questions, sometimes we’ll tackle something quite specific, and sometimes I’ll ask a question that makes you stop and think, “I’ve never looked at it like that before.”
That’s often where the interesting stuff happens.
One final piece of advice
Don’t choose a coach because they’ve convinced you that you need them.
Choose one because you feel confident they can help you think differently, explore what’s possible and make progress towards something that matters to you.
And if you’re not sure? Have a conversation. You don’t need to commit to six months of coaching just to find out whether it’s right for you.
Let’s have a chat
If you’re considering coaching and think we might be a good fit, I’d love to hear from you.
No hard sell. No pressure. Just a chance to talk about what you’re looking for and whether I can help.
